why I will not vote according to age for general conference delegates

There is much talk about the “need” for Annual Conferences to elect younger persons as delegates to General and Jurisdictional Conferences. I’ve heard some arguments for making a specfic effort to elect a clergy person who is under age 40, or perhaps under age 45. To be clear, I take very seriously the Lewis Center for Church Leadership report by Lovett Weems from last spring regarding the dramatic decline in younger clergy (their focus was on Elders under age 35). And I do think that inclusion of younger clergy leadership is critical for the church. But I’m not certain that voting for General Conference delegates simply according to age demographic is the best way of addressing that concern.

I would appreciate the opportunity to serve as a delegate, but not merely because I’m “younger clergy.” And, though the politics associated with these elections might testify to the contrary at times, I don’t view this as something that any of us “runs for.” This is about discerning who among us we would task with the work of the General Conference. As such, all persons eligible should be considered unless they have reason to remove themselves from consideration.

So, without further delay, here is why I may vote for a younger clergyperson for delegate, but not because they are younger:

1. We are not electing representatives, we are selecting delegates. A representative’s work is in representing the needs, concerns, opinions, etc. of group from which they are sent. A representative approach assumes that the makeup of the body that does the electing and sending of persons should be approximated in the makeup of the group of persons who are elected and sent. But we are not electing representatives, we are selecting delegates. A delegate is a person who is tasked with discerning and making decisions on behalf of the body that selects and sends them. This is a critical distinction, in my mind. Certainly, we do well not to ignore how the delegations is more or less representative of the whole. But, the delegation need not be representative to the Nth degree of it’s sending body. The main thing is selecting people who will serve well and faithfully lead the church.

2. “Younger clergy” are not a monolith. If only it were as simple as electing someone with a certain age range and knowing that the future direction of the church is now in good hands since a younger voice is included. But this is not the case. Younger clergy are all over the spectrum on the issues and concerns of the church today. This brings me to my final point…

3. Related to the first two, and building in particular on number 2, I have value priorities that are higher and more substantial than selecting someone in my age range as a General Conference delegate. Those priorities are: (a) Where someone is on doctrine, on the moral/ethical teaching of the church, and on missional priorities and methodology, and (b) What are someone’s leadership abilities. Put another way, (a) Am I good with the direction someone wants to see us go? and (b) Do I think they can be a part of taking us in that direction? If someone doesn’t pass those two filters for me, I’m not voting for them regardless of what demographic they fall within.

For me, I’m looking for those 2 qualities first, then looking within that subset to see what possibilities exist for having a group that aligns in some measure representatively with the Annual Conference.

Advertisements

5 thoughts on “why I will not vote according to age for general conference delegates

  1. Guy,

    Good post, and it makes perfect sense. I am glad you are looking at things more so for the betterment of the church than from any undue influence that you or someone you support would project within the general conference.

    This comment:

    “Younger clergy are all over the spectrum on the issues and concerns of the church today.”

    alone is the reason that reflective prayer and consideration for the church as a whole in your discernment of your vote is important. We see this every day in the Methoblogosphere, polar extremes within younger clergy regarding faith, the bible, and the church discipline.

    Again, thanks for the post. Even if ultimately I may not agree with a delegate you choose (which I would never know), I can be comfortable with the fact that your choice was discerned through prayer and appropriate selection criteria rather than some willie nillie, superficial, “He is 25 and has great hair,” decision making process.

    PAX
    JD

  2. Thanks, JD. I appreciate the comment…though I would mind someone thinking, “hey that Guy. 33 and great hair…wonder if he would make a good delegate…” ;^)

  3. Guy,

    Awesome post. I think the point you make about the difference between “representative” and “delegate” is something that needs to be especially reiterated. I certainly wouldn’t mind seeing younger clergy and laity as delegates, but age, race, and gender are a lot further down the list than calling, passion, and other criteria.

    P.S. I’m almost positive you won’t remember me, but I was in jr. high at FUMC Houston when you led worship for us. I’m now at Perkins in my first year.

    Peace,
    Richard Newton

  4. Wow! Thanks for reconnecting, Richard. If you’re at Annual Conference, I’d love to “re-meet” you. So great to hear that you’re at Perkins and pursuing ministry. Good stuff.

    I’ll write a brief follow-up piece, but let me go on record as saying that age is different from race and gender, in my thinking, as we consider the “make-up” of our GC delegation. Those criteria or descriptors are certainly below the ones I’m lifting up. But they are substantially different than age. I’ll have to offer an individual post to have the room to explain why.

    Thanks for the comment!

  5. Great points, Guy. I’ve had some of the same thoughts at times as I’ve heard people pushing for “young adults.” You really articulated a lot of the discomfort I have with that position. So, thanks!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s